I don’t enjoy being a Debbie Downer or a Negative Nancy, but I also don’t want to dance around it, the Santanoni Range is rough. In terms of difficulty and length it is certainly up there, but what really puts this one over is the abysmal trail conditions. With the exception of the 2-ish mile service road that takes you in from the trail head, these herd paths are technical, rocky, slippery, muddy, wet and every other ADK description you can think of.
We’ve seen quite a bit of debate about the best order to tackle these in, and we ended up taking the express trail up to Santanoni first, having heard that it was the most technically difficult aspect of the climb. Whether or not that held to be true is debatable, there were several steep and technical scrambles going up and down both sides of the loop.
The elephant in the room here is the bogs and swamps too and from Couchsacraga. They are genuinely the worst part of this, otherwise moderate, climb. Be prepared for some unpleasant wetness, and consider bringing a hiking pole to help you through the bogs. This is a draining experience and will almost certainly take about twice as long as you would expect for the relatively short distance.
Things around “Times Square,” the junction point from which all the peaks are accessible from, can be a bit of a maze; make sure you’ve got some method of orienteering for figuring this part out. The first few miles do have trail markers, but after the junction for starting the loop (the actual Santanoni Range), it’s nothing but herd paths.
Haystack is one of the tallest, and has a reputation for being sprawling and open and absolutely gorgeous, but it was storming while we summited – so we didn’t exactly see any of that. Despite our zero visibility situation, I did get a pretty good feel for how much time we were spending in open face rock and ridge paths. Even the false summit we paused on probably had great views as well.
I almost don’t want to say anything about this one because it is my last favorite of all the high peaks, I even listed it as my least favorite when filling out my 46er. My experience and impression of the range is tarnished by this peak and this trail – I fell into the bog both ways – I hate it.
I think Panther was my most favorite of the range, at least in terms of views – they were pretty good. This is the only one we actually hung out on for very long, and only ended up leaving because there was absolutely no wind and we were starting to get absolutely swarmed by flies. We will hopefully never climb up this range again, but if for some reason we do, I’ll be looking forward to the views from Panther.
Rating considers trail conditions, difficulty, views and other notable characteristics